Alexander brothers found guilty on all counts in sex trafficking trial
A jury has found the Alexander brothers guilty on all counts in their federal sex trafficking trial in New York City.
Jury deliberations began Thursday for the former real estate titans, Oren and Alon Alexander, 38-year-old twins, along with their brother, Tal Alexander, 39, who have denied sexually assaulting anyone or running a sex trafficking conspiracy, as prosecutors have charged. They pleaded not guilty.
Throughout the five-week trial, 11 women testified that they were sexually assaulted by one or more of the brothers. At least eight of the women claimed they were drugged by one of the Alexanders.
"These are chilling, reprehensible, and unacceptable acts," U.S. Attorney Jay Clayton, whose office prosecuted the case, said in a statement following the verdict. "We commend the victims for their courage in coming forward and testifying at the trial. They bravely overcame the pain of reliving the abuses inflicted upon them and, as a result, prevented others from becoming victims."
A spokesperson for the Alexander family called the verdict "deeply disappointing."
"We believe there are substantial problems with the evidence and the way this case was presented," the spokesperson, Juda S. Engelmayer, said in a statement. "The legal process does not end here. We will continue fighting every day until justice is done and the three brothers regain their freedom."
An attorney for one of the brothers also vowed to keep fighting.
"There are a lot of avenues open to us. We're not gonna stop," Marc Agnifilo, who represented Oren Alexander, said outside court on Monday. "We believe in our client's innocence and we're not gonna stop fighting until we prevail. And we believe that we will one day prevail."
The brothers' federal sentencing has been set for Aug. 6.
Oren and Tal Alexander gained notoriety in New York's luxury real estate market through their company, Alexander Group, and have been under federal investigation alongside Alon since late 2024.
They have been accused of luring women to nightclubs and parties, then drugging and sexually assaulting them.
In his closing statement, federal prosecutor Andrew Jones said there is "crushing evidence" that the brothers "masqueraded as party boys when really they were predators" who committed an "array of federal sex offenses."
Jones recounted the graphic accounts of the alleged victims and said the wealthy brothers had a "playbook" luring women with exclusive parties, yachts and luxury travel so they could assault them.
"Once they had their victims where they wanted them, the defendants assaulted them using force, using drugs, or using both," Jones said.
Then, the brothers allegedly bragged about their exploits in blog posts with titles like "It's not rape if... you use her tears as lube” and "It's not rape if... she secretly wants it.”
Jones told the jury the allegations are corroborated "by the sheer number of other victims who testified here — women who never met each other, who have each led different lives, in different professions, sometimes in different cities. But they had one horrific thing in common — they were each raped by these men. And they described near identical experiences of their assaults."
During closing arguments, defense attorney Howard Srebnick conceded the brothers could be "obnoxious" and their conduct "inappropriate," but he told the jury, "Nobody was being assaulted, nobody had been trafficked."
Srebnick urged jurors to reject the government's case against his client, Alon Alexander, insisting prosecutors failed to meet their burden of proof.
In her closing argument, Deanna Paul said the brothers "are not mobsters," though sometimes they acted like "entitled a-------."
A defense attorney for Tal Alexander, Paul argued that prosecutors have asked the jury to "connect dots that really aren't there."
In his summations, Agnifilo suggested to the jury that the victims in this case were dissatisfied with their encounters with the Alexanders, which motivated them to testify in this trial.
