Mammogram Study Reignites Controversy on Breast Cancer Screening
Sept. 29, 2010— -- A new study seems poised to reignite the debate over who should receive mammograms and when.
The Swedish study found that starting women on mammography at age 40 rather than age 50 was associated with a 26 percent reduction in risk of death from breast cancer -- a finding that raises new questions about what women 40-49 should do about mammography screening. The study comes just a week after another study, also from a Scandinavian country, found that screening mammography contributed only a 10 percent reduction in mortality.
Researchers led by Hakan Jonsson of Umea University in Umea, Sweden, reported the findings at a press briefing in advance of a presentation at the American Society of Clinical Oncology Breast Cancer Symposium. The study also was released simultaneously online in the journal Cancer.
The number of women age 40 to 49 who would need to be screened to save a single life in the Swedish study was 1,252 -- a lower figure than that seen in prior studies. But it still was higher than for older age groups given the higher breast cancer mortality later in life, Jonsson noted.
The number needed to screen is the critical issue, according to Dr. Jennifer Obel, ASCO Communications Committee member and moderator of the press briefing.
"One thing is certain," she told reporters. "Mammography has been shown in study after study to reduce the risk of breast cancer in women 40 to 49. What we're talking about is the debate about how many women need to be screened to save one life."
Dr. Donna Plecha, director of breast imaging at Case Western Reserve University in Cleveland, agreed that is the bottom line despite the back-and-forth that has been confusing for patients.
The debate erupted last year when the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) recommended that women under age 50 don't need routine screening mammography; whereas its earlier stance was in accord with American Cancer Society guidelines suggesting mammography every one to two years for all women age 40 and older.
