Uvalde officer Gonzales may have suffered from 'tunnel vision,' defense witness says
Former Uvalde, Texas, school police officer Adrian Gonzales could have suffered from "inattentive blindness" and "tunnel vision" when he responded to the Robb Elementary School shooting, a former officer testified for the defense on Tuesday.
Former San Antonio police officer Willie Cantu said the jurors are unlikely to "understand just how bad" the tunnel vision could be during an emergency response.
To describe "inattentive blindness," Cantu compared the experience to struggling to find your car keys when you are running late for work.
"It's like when you get stressed. I'm late for work and I need to find my keys to my car. I can't find my keys, and you have them in your hand," he said.
Cantu attempted to defend Gonzales’ actions on May 24, 2022 -- citing the real-time challenges he faced as one of the first officers to respond -- as defense lawyers pushed back on the prosecution's allegation that Gonzales "intentionally, knowingly, recklessly and with criminal negligence" endangered students.
Cantu also tried to cast doubt on the reliability of teaching aide Melodye Flores, who testified for the prosecution that she tried to warn Gonzales about the location of the shooter.
"No disrespect to Flores at all, she was definitely there, experienced all the trauma that was going on, but people process that type of stuff differently," Cantu said.
Cantu also attempted to highlight the inaction of other officers, including one who monitored the perimeter of the school when he arrived.
"It really surprised me that he was right there and just pretty much taken, I'd say a tertiary role," he remarked.
The only other defense witness was Claudia Rodriguez, a secretary at the funeral home that neighbored Robb.
Rodriguez told jurors that she witnessed gunman Salvador Ramos exit his car with a rifle after crashing into a ditch, and she said Ramos ducked behind a nearby parked car when Gonzales drove by him. That move, defense lawyers allege, prevented Gonzales from being able to clearly spot the gunman when he first arrived at the school.
"And at the time you see the white car [driven by Gonzales], you see the figure, kind of ducking down between the cars. Is that how you remember seeing it?" defense attorney Jason Goss asked.
"Yes sir," Rodriguez replied.
Rodriguez also testified that she tried to warn other arriving officers that the shooter entered the school, but they did not run in to stop him.
"Gilbert [Limones, another funeral home employee,] and I are yelling at them upon their arrival and after they exited their car that he's already inside," she said.
"Did those officers then go immediately to where you told them and run inside the building?" Goss asked.
"No. I believe, if I remember correctly, they got back into the car and went around the school towards the front of Robb," she said.
Defense lawyers rested their case on Tuesday after testimony from Cantu and Rodriguez. Closing statements are set for Wednesday.
Prosecutors allege Gonzales, who is charged with 29 counts of child endangerment, did not follow his training and endangered the 19 students who died and an additional 10 surviving students.
Flores, the teaching aide, testified that she repeatedly urged Gonzales to intervene in the shooting, but said he did "nothing" in those crucial moments.
Gonzales has pleaded not guilty and his lawyers argue he is being unfairly blamed for a broader law enforcement failure that day. He could face the rest of his life in prison if convicted of all counts.
