'GMA3' Deals & Steals for comfort!

Open menu

  • Video
  • Shop
  • Culture
  • Family
  • Wellness
  • Food
  • Living
  • Style
  • Travel
  • News
  • Book Club
  • GMA3: WYNTK
  • Newsletter
  • Privacy Policy
  • Your US State Privacy Rights
  • Children's Online Privacy Policy
  • Interest-Based Ads
  • Terms of Use
  • Do Not Sell My Info
  • Contact Us
  • © 2023 ABC News
  • News

Immigration lawyers say efforts to address a backlog of cases has hurt clients

VIDEO: Trump administration to deny green cards to immigrants on food stamps
1:58
Trump administration to deny green cards to immigrants on food stamps
ABCNews.com
ByIsaura Aceves
August 24, 2019, 6:33 am

In 2014, Texas immigration lawyer Robert Painter first met a domestic violence victim he believed had a strong case for asylum. But due to the backlog in U.S. immigration courts, they did not appear before a judge until last month.

The woman’s next hearing is now a year away, and Painter fears the long delay has hurt her case, and made her that much more vulnerable if she is sent back to her home country.

(MORE: Immigration News & Videos - ABC News)

Meanwhile, the sheer volume of such cases means that Painter's firm American Gateways, which represents low-income immigrants in central Texas, has been turning away as many as 140 cases a month.

“In spite of what this administration keeps trying to push, this narrative that people are trying to game the system ... it's important to remember that there are humans that are being served or not served by this system,” Painter said.

(MORE: Kids left without either parent at home for 8 days after Mississippi ICE raid)

Texas has 135,177 open immigration cases and the average wait for a hearing is 713 days, according to Syracuse University's TRAC database.

The backlog in immigration courts is nothing new. But under President Trump, the volume of open cases has swelled to just under a million people, according to TRAC.

PHOTO: Diana Ricaurte collects the drawings of the children she represents at the Central American Refugee Center in Long Island, N.Y. and hangs them on her office wall.
Diana Ricaurte collects the drawings of the children she represents at the Central American Refugee Center in Long Island, N.Y. and hangs them on her office wall.
Isaura Aceves/ABC News

Under President Obama's administration, prosecutors could ask a judge to close a case and then have it removed from the docket without a ruling. But the Department of Justice under Trump claimed that the practice was illegal and returned 350,000 deportation cases to the system.

(MORE: Trump administration to lift limit on how long migrant kids can be detained )

To address the bottleneck, the Trump administration has begun expediting family cases and hiring more judges. Immigration lawyers say they haven't had enough time to prepare some cases, while major delays can weaken other cases.

(MORE: Migrant kids at contractor shelters put 'at risk': Government watchdog)

Between the time a person claims asylum and the ruling on that application, it’s possible that the requirements have changed several times over. In a bid to limit immigration, the Trump administration is continually declaring new mandates while advocacy groups implore federal judges to block them. The result is that rules for immigrants are ever evolving.

PHOTO: Immigration lawyers are facing a growing number of challenges caused by the Trump administration efforts to solve the backlog in the immigration courts.
Immigration lawyers are facing a growing number of challenges caused by the Trump administration efforts to solve the backlog in the immigration courts.
Isaura Aceves/ABC News

Last year, the Trump administration said it would begin restricting asylum claims of migrants fleeing domestic and gang-related violence, though the directive was later rejected by a federal judge. If it is reinstated, the rule would likely mean that Painter’s client in Texas would have no case for asylum.

And last month, Attorney General William Barr ruled that if migrants pass through a country on the way to the United States and don't apply for asylum there, then they are ineligible to seek asylum in the United States.

"Adjudicating outstanding cases in the immigration backlog remains a priority for this Administration,” a Department of Justice spokesman said in a statement. “In doing so, all cases will be adjudicated in full accordance with the law and due process."

Outcome based on the law

One of the biggest changes made under the Trump administration has been to add around 200 immigration judges, which has brought the total number to 430. According to an analysis by the Associated Press, one in five judges appointed by the Trump administration are former military lawyers and attorneys who previously worked at Immigration and Custom Enforcement (ICE).

PHOTO: Anne Pilsbury, Executive Director at Central American Legal Assistance in Brooklyn, New York, works at her desk.
Anne Pilsbury, Executive Director at Central American Legal Assistance in Brooklyn, New York, works at her desk. She's seeing more of her clients having their hearing dates change without notice to sooner dates due to the Trump administration efforts to solve the backlog in the immigration courts.
Isaura Aceves/ABC News

Anne Pilsbury, an immigration lawyer in Brooklyn, New York, said inexperienced judges come with a cost.

“When [judges] first start they just don't get it. They're not used to communicating with people with limited education and they just kind of don't know how to listen and ask questions," she said. “Which makes their chances of granting the case low because if a judge finds a person not credible, it’s the end of the case."

Pilsbury, who founded Central American Legal Assistance in 1986 and remains its executive director, has worked through myriad changes to immigration rules over different administrations. She said that delays can cause evidence to become stale and supporting documents to appear outdated.

“All of a sudden the burden becomes even heavier on us to try to convince them that they're still in danger [when] it could have been granted if it was heard promptly,” Pilsbury said.

Asylum petitions currently have a roughly 70 percent denial rate, according to TRAC.

A spokeswoman at the Executive Office for Immigration Review under the Department of Justice said it is “committed to ensuring that all who come before its courts will receive due process and a timely, fair adjudication whose outcome is based on the law.”

Restrictive laws

Andrew Arthur is a fellow at the Center for Immigration Studies, a nonprofit organization that favors limiting immigration, and a former immigration judge. He said it has been important to bring in new judges and fast-tracking some cases because “it's crucial having the case heard in a timely manner.”

PHOTO: Drawings from children represented by the Central American Refugee Center in Long Island, N.Y. adorn the walls of the office.
Drawings from children represented by the Central American Refugee Center in Long Island, N.Y. adorn the walls of the office. Immigration lawyers are facing the fast tracking of their cases of family asylum seekers due to Trump administration efforts to solve the backlog in the immigration courts.
Isaura Aceves/ABC News

He said no judge is forced to rule negatively and deport people, and that judges who issue negative rulings are just following the law.

"The immigration laws in the U.S. are restrictive,” he said.

Diana Ricaurte went through an American immigrant court as a child and is now a justice fellow working with family asylum seekers and unaccompanied children through the Central American Refugee Center in Long Island.

She said she has been frustrated to find that some applicants do not in her view get a fair hearing, and that her personal experience gives her a window into how lost an asylum applicant can feel moving through the system.

“[It] doesn't give them the ability to cope with everything that's been going on, from the moment they flee to the moment that they're actually facing an immigration judge,” she said.

Related Topics
  • Immigration
Up Next in News—

'Just in shock': Dock worker assaulted in Montgomery brawl speaks out in 'GMA' exclusive

September 25, 2023

Quavo lobbies for gun violence prevention in D.C.

September 21, 2023

High school band director speaks out after getting shocked with stun gun by police

September 20, 2023

Former New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern says it wasn't burnout that led her to step down

September 20, 2023

Up Next in News—

'Just in shock': Dock worker assaulted in Montgomery brawl speaks out in 'GMA' exclusive

September 25, 2023

Quavo lobbies for gun violence prevention in D.C.

September 21, 2023

High school band director speaks out after getting shocked with stun gun by police

September 20, 2023

Former New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern says it wasn't burnout that led her to step down

September 20, 2023

The latest lifestyle and entertainment news and inspiration for how to live your best life - all from Good Morning America.
  • Contests
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Do Not Sell My Info
  • Children’s Online Privacy Policy
  • Advertise with us
  • Your US State Privacy Rights
  • Interest-Based Ads
  • About Nielsen Measurement
  • Press
  • Feedback
  • ABC News
  • ABC
  • All Videos
  • All Topics
  • Sitemap

© 2023 ABC News
  • Privacy Policy— 
  • Your US State Privacy Rights— 
  • Children's Online Privacy Policy— 
  • Interest-Based Ads— 
  • Terms of Use— 
  • Do Not Sell My Info— 
  • Contact Us— 

© 2023 ABC News